The Fake Special Report
86% of the Takealot products showing a discount have never sold at their "was" price in the 48 days Watchalot has tracked them: 5 776 of 6 747 products. The average discount claimed is 32%. Measured against what the same products usually sold for, the average real saving is 4%.
Why this happens
Takealot works out its discounts from a list price: the recommended retail price the supplier gives it, which the supplier can change at any time. A discount measured from that price says nothing about whether the product is cheaper than usual. How Takealot calculates discounts explains it in more detail. We don't suggest anyone is breaking a rule: the regulator has more than once accepted a supplier's list price as a fair "was" price. These figures show what the system means for shoppers.
By department
Departments with at least 30 discounted products, biggest gap between the claimed discount and the real saving first.
| Department | Discounted | Claimed | Real saving |
|---|---|---|---|
| Luggage & Travel | 250 | 38% | 2% |
| Cellphones & Wearables | 339 | 38% | 3.2% |
| Automotive | 370 | 36% | 2.1% |
| TV, Audio & Video | 418 | 34% | 2.7% |
| Gaming | 378 | 33% | 2.3% |
| Computers & Tablets | 310 | 33% | 2.6% |
| DIY Tools & Machinery | 475 | 33% | 2.5% |
| Office & Stationery | 456 | 32% | 2% |
| Home & Kitchen | 300 | 33% | 4.6% |
| Camping & Outdoors | 363 | 32% | 3.6% |
| Sport | 249 | 32% | 4.3% |
| Garden, Pool & Patio | 390 | 29% | 1.9% |
| Toys | 364 | 30% | 3.5% |
| Cameras | 321 | 29% | 2.7% |
| Beauty | 401 | 33% | 8.1% |
| Baby & Toddler | 263 | 34% | 9.7% |
| Health | 381 | 29% | 5.3% |
| Pets | 359 | 23% | 5.4% |
| Household, Food & Beverages | 352 | 26% | 8.9% |
Examples
A well-reviewed product from each of the five departments with the biggest gap.
- Marco Slim Card Holder Wallet - Black PU Double Sided Card Wallet 6 Slots (Luggage & Travel): shown as 32% off, "was" R131. In 42 days it never sold for more than R89, and usually sold for R89. Today: R89.
- M10 Wireless Earphone with Power Bank Charging Case (Cellphones & Wearables): shown as 51% off, "was" R199. In 42 days it never sold for more than R102, and usually sold for R99. Today: R98.
- 4 Pieces Universal Car Rubber Floor Mats (Black) (Automotive): shown as 55% off, "was" R359. In 42 days it never sold for more than R183, and usually sold for R155. Today: R162.
- Volkano Bluetooth Wireless Headphones | Phonic Series - Rose (TV, Audio & Video): shown as 38% off, "was" R399. In 48 days it never sold for more than R299, and usually sold for R279. Today: R249.
- Mix Box 90x40cm Extra Large Non-Slip World Map Speed Game Mouse Pad Mat (Gaming): shown as 67% off, "was" R299. In 48 days it never sold for more than R99, and usually sold for R99. Today: R99.
How we worked it out
- The products. Every morning Watchalot reads the prices Takealot shows for 16 522 products: the popular and top-rated listings of 19 departments, plus products visitors add. It's a large sample of what people buy, not all of Takealot.
- The period. Daily prices since 3 October 2026: 48 days to 19 November 2026.
- "Discounted" means Takealot showed a "was" price above the selling price on 19 November 2026, for a product we had tracked for at least 14 days.
- "Never sold at its was price" means the highest daily price we recorded stayed below that "was" price the whole time. Prices are checked once a day, so a price that lasted only a few hours between checks would be missed.
- The real saving compares today's price with the product's usual price: the median of its daily prices over the last 90 days (or all the days we have). A price above usual counts as no saving.
- A fake special shows a "was" price, but sold for today's price or less in the 60 days before.
The figures update every day. When quoting them, please give the date above. For figures on a specific department or product, get in touch: haiko@dontsp.am.