How Takealot calculates discounts
The short version: a Takealot discount is measured from the supplier's list price, not from what the product has recently sold for. So the percentage tells you how far today's price is below a price the supplier chose, which the product may never have sold at. To know whether a special is real, compare today's price with what it actually sold for in the weeks before.
The list price
Next to the selling price, Takealot shows a crossed-out "was" price and a percentage off. That "was" price is the list price: the recommended retail price the supplier gives Takealot. The percentage is simply the gap between the two:
discount = (list price − selling price) ÷ list price
A product selling for R700 with a list price of R1 000 shows as 30% off, whatever it sold for last week.
Why it can mislead
The supplier can change the list price whenever they like. Raise it from R999 to R1 399 and a product still selling for R979 goes from 2% off to 30% off, without its price dropping a cent. In 2021, MyBroadband reported a TV whose list price jumped from R10 999 to R14 999 for a day, which took its advertised discount from 9% to 33%.
This isn't a matter of anyone breaking a rule. Shoppers have challenged list-price discounts with the advertising regulator (the ASA, now the Advertising Regulatory Board), and rulings have gone both ways, but the regulator has more than once accepted the supplier's recommended price as a fair "was" price. Takealot also isn't a member of the ARB, so the board's rulings don't bind it. So the practice carries on.
How often it happens
Watchalot records the daily prices of thousands of popular Takealot products. Most of the products showing a discount have never sold at their "was" price in all the days we've tracked them, and the average real saving is a small fraction of the average discount claimed. The current figures, with the method, are in the Fake Special Report.
How to check a special
- Ignore the percentage. It only compares today's price with the list price.
- Look at the price history. What did it sell for over the last few weeks? A real deal is below that, not just below the "was" price.
- Watch for price rises before a sale. A price that went up a few weeks before Black Friday and then comes back down saves you nothing.
- Paste the link into Watchalot. Paste any Takealot product link on watchalot.co.za to see its daily price history and a plain verdict: Real deal Normal price or Fake special. If we don't track it yet, we start that day.
Getting ready for Black Friday? See today's real deals and fake specials.
Sources: Takealot's help centre on how discounts are calculated; ASA rulings on Takealot list prices (2018–2019); MyBroadband, December 2021; Watchalot's own daily price records.